U.S. CHAMBER OF COMMERCE

Global Energy Institute - Beveridge & Diamond
Energy Tracker

Welcome to the Global Energy Institute - Beveridge & Diamond Energy Tracker. This site is intended to serve as a one-stop resource for monitoring key regulatory, judicial, and legislative developments associated with the Trump Administration’s energy policy agenda.

The Tracker interface immediately below provides a comprehensive, filterable and sortable list of energy-related federal actions tracked by date, agency, high-level topic area, and specific issue. The default view displays entries in reverse chronological order of the most recent substantive action by the relevant agency or court.

The Tracker will be updated regularly. This edition is updated through April 3, 2018. Notable developments over the last month include:

  • 3/12/18: EPA finalizes proposal to stay deadlines pertaining to stay certain requirements associated with 2016 methane NSPS rule.

  • 3/12/18: Court issues opinion upholding FERC waiver overruling New York’s permit denial for Millennium’s Valley Lateral pipeline.

  • 3/13/18: EPA issues guidance memo clarifying application of “project netting” determinations associated with NSR permitting requirements. For a detailed summary of this and related actions, please see this Beveridge and Diamond News Alert.

  • 3/16/18: D.C. Circuit holds oral arguments in challenge to EPA delay of Risk Management Plan regulation (Air Alliance Houston v. EPA, No. 17-1155).

  • 3/23/18: U.S. District Court of North Dakota issues order granting states’ request to resume litigation on WOTUS rule.

  • 3/26/18: Environmental petitioners file for review of EPA’s final action reversing “once-in, always-in” policy under section 112 of the Clean Air Act.

  • 3/27/18: National Highway Traffic Safety Administration proposes to retain civil penalties for auto manufacturer CAFE violations, rejecting Obama Administration proposal to increase fines.

  • 4/3/18: EPA announces completion of the Midterm Evaluation (MTE) process for light duty vehicle GHG standards for model years 2022-2025, determining that current standards are not appropriate and should be revised.

In addition to the comprehensive tracking database below, cumulative data quantifying the status and progress of Trump Administration energy actions is tabulated in this simplified quick reference list. As of this edition of the Tracker, energy-related actions taken by President Trump include 8 executive orders, 4 presidential memoranda, and provisions in 5 public laws. Further, by our best estimate, there are currently 16 energy-related regulatory/policy reforms initiated or under review, 7 reforms formally proposed, and 21 reform actions that have been finalized or completed. (These figures do not include project-specific actions such as leases or permit approvals.)

In addition, litigation pertaining to at least 16 actions is underway or ongoing. Among these, seven regulatory-related court cases are currently being held in abeyance, and in 3 instances court action has overturned Executive Branch postponement of regulatory implementation.

Please contact Dan Byers of GEI (dbyers@uschamber.com) or David Friedland of Beveridge and Diamond (dfriedland@bdlaw.com, 202.789.6047) with questions, updates, or suggestions. For specific legal documents, please contact Beveridge and Diamond.

 

Energy Tracker

Indicates Public Law
Topic Issue/Reg Order/Action Most Recent Action Agency Litigation (if any) Notes/Info/Chamber Statements
Vehicles / Fuels CAFE Standards
  • 4/3/2018

    EPA announces completion of the Midterm Evaluation (MTE) process for light duty vehicle GHG standards for model years 2022-2025, determining that current standards are not appropriate and should be revised.

  • 3/27/2018

    The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration proposes to retain civil penalties for auto manufacturer CAFE violations, rejecting Obama Administration proposal to increase fines.

    (Press release)

  • 8/21/2018

    NHTSA and EPA announce formal reconsideration of light-duty vehicle GHG standards for model years 2022-2025. 

    (Comment docket)

  • 7/26/2017

    National Highway Traffic Safety Administration announces public comment period for scoping environmental impact assessment associated with new Corporate Average Fuel Economy (CAFE) standards for model year 2022-2025 passenger vehicles

  • 3/15/2017

    President Trump directs EPA to reopen mid-term review of light-duty mileage standards for cars and trucks.

more
  • EPA
  • DOT
    Land Management / Leasing Sale of Federal Property
      • Interior
      • 4/2/2018

        Federal Petitioners file suit against the State of California for enacting SB50, which makes it the policy of the State of California to discourage conveyance of federal public lands in the State away from the federal government.

      Case: United States v. State of California, No. 2:18-at-00406 (E.D. Ca. Apr. 2, 2018)

      Land Management / Leasing Outer Continental Shelf (OCD) Oil and Gas Leasing
      • 3/30/2018

        BOEM issues request for information to solicit industry nominations for areas of leasing interest in Alaska’s Beaufort Sea.

      • Interior
        Air Regulations CAA Section 112
        • EPA
        • 3/26/2018

          Environmental petitioners file for review of EPA’s final action reversing once-in, always-in policy.

        Water Regulations / Fracking Waters of the U.S. (WOTUS)
        • 2/6/2018

          EPA finalizes proposal delaying effective implementation date of the 2015 WOTUS rule until February 6, 2020.

          (Agency press release)

        • 11/22/2017

          EPA proposes to delay the effective implementation date of the WOTUS rule until 2020, to ensure that the prior definition of “waters of the United States” remains in effect while further changes to the definition are considered. (Regulations.gov docket)

           

        • 6/28/2017

          EPA, Army Corps formally propose repeal of 2015 Waters of the U.S. regulation and announce intention to pursue follow-on rulemaking revising definition of “waters of the United States” under the Clean Water Act.

          (Federal Register)

        • 2/28/2017

          Executive Order 13778 directing EPA to review and reconsider its “Waters of the United States” (WOTUS) regulation.

        more
        • Potus
        • EPA
        • 3/23/2018

          U.S. District Court of North Dakota issues an order granting states’ request to resume litigation on WOTUS rule.

        • 2/28/2018

          6th Circuit lifts nationwide stay of the Waters of the U.S. rule.

        • 1/22/2018

          Supreme Court issues an opinion concluding that the final rule under review is not the kind of action the Act requires be originally heard in the Courts of Appeal, thereby determining that that litigation involving EPA’s “Waters of the U.S.” regulation and other Clean Water Act rules should be heard by federal district courts.

        • 11/22/2017

          Federal Respondents file notice of publication of proposed rule.

           

        • 6/30/2017

          EPA files notice of publication of proposed rulemaking to re-codify the definition of WOTUS.

        • 4/3/2017

          Supreme Court denies Trump Administration request to halt review of case to determine appropriate jurisdiction. (Supreme Court argument scheduled 10/11/17).

        • 1/25/2017

          6th Circuit grants abeyance in Murray Energy v. EPA lawsuit against (stayed) WOTUS regulation, pending Trump Administration review of the rule.

        • 1/13/2017

          Supreme Court grants certiorari on motion by Murray Energy v. EPA intervenor National Association of Manufacturers regarding which federal court has jurisdiction over EPA’s Waters of the U.S. rule.

        • 7/13/2015

          Industry petitioners file for review of Agency final action defining “Waters of the United States” in Murray Energy v. EPA.

        more

        12/13/17: U.S. Chamber comments on proposal to delay WOTUS implementation date.

        Waters Advocacy Coalition 9/27/17 letter on proposed WOTUS repeal.

        U.S. Chamber 9/25/17 comments on proposed WOTUS repeal.

        Coalition letter supporting executive order on WOTUS rule.

        Blog and Chamber statement: EPA Will Repeal Obama’s Land-Grabbing Water Rule.

        Litigation details at Chamber Litigation Center

        Case: Murray Energy v. EPA, No. 15-3751 (6th Cir.)

        Case: Nat’l Assn. of Mfr. v. Dep’t of Def., No. 16-299 (S. Ct.)

        Land Management / Leasing Oil and Gas Leasing
        • 3/21/2018

          BOEM announces results of Lease Sale 250

        • 2/16/2018

          Interior’s Bureau of Ocean Energy Management schedules Lease Sale 250 for March 21, 2018. The sale will include all available unleased areas in the Gulf of Mexico and will be the largest lease sale in U.S. history.

          (Interior press release)

        • 10/24/2017

          Secretary Zinke announces auction for over 76 million acres of offshore oil and gas leases in the Gulf of Mexico for March 2018 (lease sale 250).

        more
        • Interior

          According to Interior, this is the largest oil and gas lease sale in U.S. history, offering an area about the size of New Mexico. 

          Air Regulations Risk Management Plan
          • 6/14/2017

            Administrator Pruitt signs directive delaying implementation of the Obama Administration’s January 5, 2017, Risk Management Plan amendments for 20 months while the agency reviews petitions for reconsideration against the rule brought by states and industry.

            (News Summary)

            (Federal Register notice)

          • EPA
          • 3/16/2018

            Oral arguments held.

          • 1/31/2018

            Industry intervenors file their final reply brief.

          • 1/31/2018

            Industry intervenors file their final brief.

          • 1/31/2018

            State intervenors file their final brief.

             

          • 1/30/2018

            State petitioners file their final opening brief.

             

          • 1/30/2018

            State petitioners file their final reply brief.

          • 1/19/2018

            State and industry intervenors file their reply proof briefs.

          • 12/8/2017

            EPA files preliminary brief defending its authority to issue a delay rule for the Risk Management Plan.

          • 11/3/2017

            EPA files preliminary brief defending its authority to issue a delay rule for the Risk Management Plan.

          • 11/1/2017

            Former Regulatory Officials file amicus for Petitioners arguing that rule effective dates are substantive and subject to APA procedural standards

          • 10/25/2017

            State and Industry petitioners file their respective briefs.

          • 9/26/2017

            Court adopts the parties’ jointly proposed briefing schedule; Opening briefs due Oct. 25, 2017.

          • 8/30/2017

            D.C. Circuit denies motion to stay case (filed by intervenors United Steel, et al. on 6/22/17).

          • 6/15/2017

            Environmental groups file for review of final Agency action to delay Risk Management Plan rule implementation.

          • 12/22/2017

            State and industry intervenors file briefs in support of respondent EPA.

          more

          Chamber statement on EPA proposal to delay the effective date of the rule.

          Revised effective date of the rule is 2/19/19.

          Case: Air Alliance Houston v. EPA, No. 17-1155 (D.C. Cir.)

          Air Regulations Venting and Flaring
          • 2/22/2018

            BLM publishes proposed revisions to the Methane and Waste Prevention Rule

            (Agency press release)

            (Comment docket)

          • 2/12/2018

            BLM announces proposal to revise Methane Waste Prevention Rule.

            (Agency press release)

             

          • 12/8/2017

            BLM finalizes proposal to delay implementation of venting and flaring rule until January 2019.

          • 10/5/2017

            BLM formally proposes to temporarily suspend implementation of 2016 venting and flaring rule until January 2019. 

          • 6/15/2017

            BLM announces it will suspend implementation of certain provisions of November 2016 Methane Waste Prevention Rule (aka Venting and Flaring) that have yet to go into effect.

          • 3/28/2017

            Section 7 of Executive Order 13783 directs review and reconsideration of Department of Interior methane regulations for oil and gas production on federal lands (aka venting and flaring).

          more
          • Potus
          • Interior
          • 3/15/2018

            9th Cir. enters order granting Appellants’ voluntary motion to dismiss.

          • 3/14/2018

            Appellants file voluntary motion to dismiss appeal.

          • 12/8/2017

            Case docketed before the Court of Appeals for the 9th Circuit.

          • 12/4/2017

            BLM files Notice of Appeal to the Ninth Cir.

          • 10/4/2017

            U.S. District Court for Northern California invalidates Department of Interior’s administrative stay of BLM methane waste prevention rule.

          • 7/5/2017

            State petitioners file suit against the Bureau of Land Management for postponing the compliance date of the Waste Prevention, Production Subject to Royalties and Resource Conservation rule.

          more

          Chamber key vote letter supporting congressional repeal of venting and flaring rule (5/9/17).

          Coalition letter supporting congressional repeal of venting and flaring rule (2/2/17).

          Case: California v. BLM, no. 17-cv-03804-EDL (N.D. Ca.)

          Case: California v. BLM, no. 17-17456 (9th Cir.).

          Air Regulations New Source Review
          • 3/13/2018

            EPA issues guidance memorandum clarifying when proposed projects will trigger New Source Review (“NSR”) under the Clean Air Act.

          • 12/7/2017

            EPA issues guidance memo on NSR permitting requirements stating that EPA will generally defer to a facility’s “actual-to-projected-actual” calculations for purposes of preconstruction permitting.

          • EPA

            Beveridge and Diamond News Alert summarizing NSR updates (3/28/18)

            Air Regulations Ozone NAAQS
            • 3/9/2018

              EPA issues threshold implementation guidance setting attainment timelines for 2015 ozone rule.

              (Agency fact sheet)

            • 1/5/2018

              EPA announces its intention to complete attainment designations for the 2015 ozone standard by 4/30/18.

            • 11/16/2017

              EPA issues attainment designations for 2,646 counties under the 2015 ozone standard; indicates remaining designations (15% of U.S. counties) will be issued at a later date.

              (News Summary)

            • 8/2/2017

              EPA withdraws prior decision to extending attainment designation deadlines.

            • 6/7/2017

              EPA postpones 2015 ozone standard attainment designations for one year, citing insufficient information to make compliance decision.

            more
            • EPA
            • 3/12/2018

              Court enters order granting NGO plaintiffs’ and state plaintiffs’ motions for summary judgment, confirming that the Administrator violated a nondiscretionary duty under the Clean Air Act to promulgate NAAQS for Ozone by Oct 1, 2017 (No. 17-6900).

            • 2/16/2018

              D.C. Cir. issues an opinion ruling that 1) EPA failed to adopt adequate anti-backsliding measures when it revoked the 1997 NAAQS, 2) EPA violated the CAA by allowing so-called “orphan nonattainment areas” to evade anti-backsliding requirements, 3) the rule’s invitation of “redesignation substitute requests” evaded the statutory requirements for redesignations, and 4) EPA failed to provide a statutory justification for allowing states to choose their own baseline year for measuring pollution reductions (No. 15-1115).

               

            • 1/31/2018

              State of California files its reply in support of motion for summary judgment.

               

            • 1/26/2018

              Environmental groups file their reply in support of motion for summary judgment.

            • 1/19/2018

              EPA files its opposition  to environmental group plaintiffs’ motion for summary judgment.

               

            • 1/8/2018

              EPA submits status report,  stating it is continuing to review the Rule in Murray Energy.

            • 10/10/2017

              EPA submits status report stating it is continuing to review the Rule.

            • 8/1/2017

              Coalition of 15 states sues EPA to block postponement of ozone standard implementation. 

            • 7/10/2017

              In its 90-day status report, EPA states it is continuing to review Rule. EPA will submit its next status report within 90 days.

            • 4/11/2017

              D.C. Circuit grants indefinite abeyance of 2015 ozone standard lawsuit, delaying previously scheduled oral argument and ordering EPA to provide updates at 90 day intervals.

            • 10/26/2015

              Industry petitioners file for review of agency’s proposed Ozone NAAQS rule.

            more

            Blog: EPA Delays Implementing Ozone Standard for One Year

            EPA’s Tightened Ozone Standard Will Harm America’s Economic Growth.

            Case details at Chamber Litigation Center.

            Case: Murray Energy v. EPA, No. 15-1385 (D.C. Cir.)

            Permitting / NEPA Pipelines
            • 11/15/2017

              FERC denies NY’s motion for rehearing and stay.

               

            • 9/15/2017

              FERC overrules NY Department of Environmental Conservation’s denial of water permit for Millennium Pipeline’s Valley Lateral project, citing failure to meet one-year decision deadline.

              (News Summary)

            • FERC
            • 3/12/2018

              Court issues opinion denying petition for review, thereby upholding FERC waiver overruling New York’s permit denial for Millennium’s Valley Lateral pipeline. Court agrees that New York took too long reviewing the permit application

            • 1/2/2018

              Court sets oral argument for January 24.

            • 12/15/2017

              Intervenor-environmental group files petition for emergency stay of construction near the vicinity of a bald eagle nest. Motion denied by the court.

            • 12/8/2017

              Court sets oral argument for 1/24/18.

            • 11/28/2017

              NY files reply brief in support of its emergency motion to stay.

               

            • 11/20/2017

              FERC files its opposition to NY’s emergency motion to stay.

            • 11/17/2017

              NY files emergency motion to stay FERC order.

            • 11/17/2017

              NY files petition for review of agency order.

               

            more

            Case: NY DEC v. FERC, No. 17-3770 (2nd Cir.)

            Air Regulations Methane NSPS
            • 3/12/2018

              EPA finalizes proposal to stay deadlines pertaining to stay certain requirements associated with 2016 methane NSPS rule.

            • 11/8/2017

              EPA issues notice seeking comment on numerous aspects of its June 2017 proposal to stay certain requirements of the 2016 rule.

              (Agency fact sheet)

            • 6/16/2017

              EPA issues order proposing to stay for two years the implementation of 2016 new source performance standards pertaining to methane in oil and gas production during review and reconsideration of the rule. 

            • 6/5/2017

              EPA issues a 90-day stay of agency rules limiting methane leaks at drilling sites.

            more
            • EPA
            • 8/10/2017

              Industry and State petitioners’ request for a rehearing en banc denied.

            • 7/31/2017

              D.C. Circuit en banc panel vacates EPA’s 90-day pause of methane rule implementation for new oil and gas sources, putting the rule back into effect.

            • 7/13/2017

              D.C. Circuit grants EPA request to delay enforcement of methane NSPS regulation for 14 days while the agency considers whether to appeal the ruling. (EPA had requested 45 day enforcement delay).

            • 7/3/2017

              D.C. Circuit invalidates EPA two-year administrative stay of 2016 methane NSPS regulation; orders immediate enforcement of rule.

            • 6/5/2017

              Environmental petitioners file for review of EPA’s final action staying its own standards of performance for the oil and gas sector.

            more

            Case: Clean Air Council v. EPA, No. 17-1145 (D.C. Cir.)

            Air Regulations Regional Haze
              • EPA
              • 3/12/2018

                In status report to 10th Circuit, EPA says it plans to develop a new regional haze plan for Utah after completing new air quality modeling simulations later this spring. 

              • 9/11/2017

                10th Circuit grants request from PacifiCorp and State of Utah to stay litigation on EPA’s 2016 regional haze federal implementation plan (FIP) while EPA reconsiders the rule.

              Energy Financial / Royalties Waste Prevention Rule
              • 11/18/2016

                BLM issues final rule promulgating new regulations to reduce waste of natural gas from venting, flaring and leaks during oil and gas production activities.

              • Interior
              • 3/9/2018

                BLM files answer to complaint (Case. No. 17-7186).

              • 2/22/2018

                Court enters order denying BLM’s motion to transfer venue and granting preliminary injunction (No. 17-7186).

              • 2/26/2018

                Court enters order granting Trade Associations’ motion to intervene (No. 17-7187).

                 

              • 12/19/2017

                States file complaint against BLM (No. 17-7186).

              • 12/1/2017

                Environmental groups file complaint against BLM (No. 17-7187).

              more

              Consolidated cases:

              California v. BLM, No. 17-7186 (N.D. CA).

              Sierra Club v. BLM, No. 17-7187 (N.D. CA).

              Air Regulations Ozone NAAQS
              • 3/9/2018

                EPA proposes withdrawal of “control technique guidelines” (CTGs) related to recommendations to states for controlling VOCs from existing oil and gas facilities in ozone nonattainment areas and the ozone transport region.

                (Comment docket)

              • EPA
                Permitting / NEPA Pipelines
                • 2/3/2017

                  FERC grants final permit approvals for Atlantic Sunrise Pipeline.

                • FERC
                • 3/9/2018

                  Petitioners file their joint appellate opening brief.

                • 2/16/2018

                  Court enters order denying motion for stay.

                • 1/16/2018

                  Environmental Groups file motion to stay and enjoin all pipeline construction and all ground disturbing activities in Pennsylvania.

                • 11/8/2017

                  Court enters order dissolving the 11/6/17 administrative stay order and denying emergency motion for stay.

                   

                • 11/8/2017

                  D.C. Cir. lifts its 11/6 stay, allowing construction to proceed.

                • 11/6/2017

                  D.C. Cir. stays the FERC order pending further review Plaintiffs’ emergency motion.

                • 10/30/2017

                  Environmental petitioners file an emergency motion to stay pipeline construction.

                • 3/23/2017

                  Environmental groups file for review of final FERC order authorizing construction of the Transcontinental Gas Pipe Line Co. Atlantic Sunrise Project issued in February of 2017.  

                more
                Land Management / Leasing Monuments
                • 3/9/2018

                  Department of Interior announces four public scoping meetings as part of ongoing land use planning for Bears Ears National Monument (BENM) and Grand Staircase-Escalante National Monument (GSENM).

                • Interior
                  Permitting / NEPA Pipelines
                  • 2/2/2016

                    FERC grants permit authorizing construction of Sabal Trail pipeline in Florida.

                  • Energy
                  • 3/7/2018

                    Court enters order denying Duke Energy et al.’s motion to stay the issuance of mandate and granting FERC’s motion to stay issuance of mandate (thereby allowing FERC until 3/26 to complete NEPA climate review).

                  • 2/6/2018

                    Industry intervenors file motion to stay mandate.

                  • 2/6/2018

                    FERC files motion to stay mandate.

                  • 12/4/2017

                    Intervenors file supplemental reply in support of rehearing petition.

                  • 12/4/2017

                    Intervenors file opposition to Petitioners’ motion for leave to file supplemental response.

                  • 11/27/2017

                    Petitioners file motion for leave to file supplemental response opposing petition for rehearing.

                  • 11/16/2017

                    Intervenors file reply in support of petition for rehearing.

                  • 11/13/2017

                    Respondents file their opposition to Petitioners’ petition for rehearing.

                  • 11/10/2017

                    Environmental petitioners file petition for rehearing.

                  • 10/6/2017

                    Respondent FERC and Intervenors file petitions for rehearing

                  • 8/22/2017

                    D.C. Circuit remands FERC’s EIS for failure to consider downstream greenhouse-gas emissions pipelines serviced by the Sabal Trail pipeline.

                  • 9/21/2016

                    Environmental Group files for review of agency determination approving Sabal Trail pipeline.

                  more

                  Case: Sierra Club v. FERC, No. 16-1329 (D.C. Cir.)

                  Air Regulations Clean Power Plan (Existing Source Performance Standards)
                  • 2/1/2018

                    EPA announces additional public hearings on proposed CPP repeal, and extends comment deadline until 4/26/18.

                  • 11/8/2017

                    EPA announces public hearing on proposed CPP repeal, and extends comment deadline on proposal to 1/18/18.

                  • 10/23/2015

                    Final Clean Power Plan published in Federal Register.

                  • 10/16/2017

                    EPA announces proposal to repeal Clean Power Plan and plans for Advance Notice of Proposed Rulemaking (ANPRM) to solicit comment on whether further regulatory action is warranted. (Link to comment docket)

                  • 6/9/2017

                    EPA submits proposed CPP changes to OMB for review. 

                  • 3/28/2017

                    Section 4 of Executive Order 13783 directs review and reconsideration of EPA Clean Power Plan.

                  more
                  • Potus
                  • EPA
                  • 3/1/2018

                    Court enters order directing EPA to continue filing status reports at 30-day intervals.

                  • 2/9/2018

                    EPA submits status report stating it is considering scope of potential new rule and requests the court to continue to hold case in abeyance.

                  • 1/17/2018

                    Public health and environmental organizations file their opposition to EPA’s request for further abeyance.

                     

                  • 1/17/2018

                    State and Municipal Respondents file their opposition to EPA’s request for further abeyance.

                  • 1/10/2018

                    EPA submits status report stating it is considering scope of potential new rule and requests the court to continue to hold case in abeyance.

                  • 12/11/2017

                    EPA submits status report stating it is considering scope of potential new rule and requests the court to continue to hold case in abeyance.

                  • 11/9/2017

                    D.C. Circuit grants 60-day abeyance; orders EPA to provide 30-day status updates.

                  • 10/17/2017

                    Intervenors file their response to EPA’s status report and request for indefinite abeyance.

                  • 10/10/2017

                    EPA submits status report, stating that the Administrator signed a proposed rule to repeal the Clean power Plan. EPA requests the court to continue to hold case in abeyance.

                  • 9/7/2017

                    EPA submits status report, stating that the proposed rule will be published in Fall 2017 for public comment. EPA requests the court to continue to hold case in abeyance.

                  • 8/8/2017

                    D.C. Circuit grants another 60-day abeyance; reminds EPA that it has “affirmative statutory obligation to regulate greenhouse gases.” (Court Order)

                  • 4/28/2017

                    D.C. Circuit grants 60-day abeyance; orders EPA to provide 30 day status updates. Abeyance granted through approximately June 27.

                  more

                  Global Energy Institute statement on proposed repeal of Clean Power Plan (10/10/17)

                  Energy Institute information on Clean Power Plan and EPA carbon regulations.

                  Litigation details at U.S. Chamber Litigation Center.

                  Case: West Virginia v. EPA, No. 15-1363 (D.C. Cir.)

                  Permitting / NEPA Pipelines
                  • 2/17/2017

                    Army Corps issues Notice of Termination of the Intent To Prepare an Environmental Impact Statement in Connection With Dakota Access, LLC, approving the final easement for the pipeline.

                  • 1/24/2017

                    Presidential Memorandum declaring the Dakota Access Pipeline in the national interest, and directing relevant federal agencies to expedite review of the pipeline.

                  • 2/28/2018

                    Dakota Access files its Status Report.

                  • 2/9/2018

                    Defendants’ file reply briefs in support of their motions for summary judgment.

                  • 2/7/2018

                    Plaintiffs file their response to defendant’s second status report.

                  • 2/1/2018

                    Army Corps of Engineers files its second status report.

                  • 1/26/2018

                    Plaintiffs file reply brief in support their motion for partial summary judgment.

                  • 1/10/2018

                    Army Corps of Engineers files a summary judgment motion.

                  • 1/10/2018

                    Dakota Access files a summary judgment motion.

                  • 12/29/2017

                    Dakota Access files its first status report.

                  • 12/4/2017

                    Court enters order directing 1) the parties to coordinate finalizing an oil-spill response plan, and 2) Intervenor Dakota Access to select an independent engineering company, and 3) Intervenor Dakota Access to submit bi-monthly reports to the Court.

                  • 11/15/2017

                    Environmental petitioners file reply brief in support of their motion for imposition of remand condition.

                  • 11/13/2017

                    Environmental petitioners file motion for partial summary judgment.

                  • 11/1/2017

                    Defendant files opposition to petitioners’ motion for imposition of remand conditions.

                  • 11/1/2017

                    Intervenor files its motion regarding imposition of remand conditions.

                  • 10/11/2017

                    District Court enters a decision allowing Dakota Access pipeline to stay in operation while U.S. Army Corps of Engineers conducts further environmental review of the project.

                  • 10/6/2017

                    Court grants Plaintiff’s Motion to Amend Protective Order.

                  • 6/14/2017

                    D.C. District Court rules in part that certain portions of the approved site must be re-evaluated but leaves open the question of whether the Corps must stop working on the pipeline

                  • 7/27/2016

                    Environmental petitioners file for review of final agency authorization of construction of the Dakota Access Pipeline.

                  more

                  Chamber applauds final approval of the Dakota Access Pipeline.

                  Blog: Oil is Flowing Through the Dakota Access Pipeline, and North Dakota is Benefiting.

                  Case: Standing Rock Sioux Tribe v. Army Corps of Engineers, No. 17-cv-267 (D.D.C.)

                  Case details at Chamber litigation center

                  Topic
                  Air Regulations
                  Issue/Reg
                  Clean Power Plan (Existing Source Performance Standards)
                  Order/Action
                  • 2/1/2018

                    EPA announces additional public hearings on proposed CPP repeal, and extends comment deadline until 4/26/18.

                  • 11/8/2017

                    EPA announces public hearing on proposed CPP repeal, and extends comment deadline on proposal to 1/18/18.

                  • 10/23/2015

                    Final Clean Power Plan published in Federal Register.

                  • 10/16/2017

                    EPA announces proposal to repeal Clean Power Plan and plans for Advance Notice of Proposed Rulemaking (ANPRM) to solicit comment on whether further regulatory action is warranted. (Link to comment docket)

                  • 6/9/2017

                    EPA submits proposed CPP changes to OMB for review. 

                  • 3/28/2017

                    Section 4 of Executive Order 13783 directs review and reconsideration of EPA Clean Power Plan.

                  more
                  Most Recent Action
                  Litigation
                  • 3/1/2018

                    Court enters order directing EPA to continue filing status reports at 30-day intervals.

                  • 2/9/2018

                    EPA submits status report stating it is considering scope of potential new rule and requests the court to continue to hold case in abeyance.

                  • 1/17/2018

                    Public health and environmental organizations file their opposition to EPA’s request for further abeyance.

                     

                  • 1/17/2018

                    State and Municipal Respondents file their opposition to EPA’s request for further abeyance.

                  • 1/10/2018

                    EPA submits status report stating it is considering scope of potential new rule and requests the court to continue to hold case in abeyance.

                  • 12/11/2017

                    EPA submits status report stating it is considering scope of potential new rule and requests the court to continue to hold case in abeyance.

                  • 11/9/2017

                    D.C. Circuit grants 60-day abeyance; orders EPA to provide 30-day status updates.

                  • 10/17/2017

                    Intervenors file their response to EPA’s status report and request for indefinite abeyance.

                  • 10/10/2017

                    EPA submits status report, stating that the Administrator signed a proposed rule to repeal the Clean power Plan. EPA requests the court to continue to hold case in abeyance.

                  • 9/7/2017

                    EPA submits status report, stating that the proposed rule will be published in Fall 2017 for public comment. EPA requests the court to continue to hold case in abeyance.

                  • 8/8/2017

                    D.C. Circuit grants another 60-day abeyance; reminds EPA that it has “affirmative statutory obligation to regulate greenhouse gases.” (Court Order)

                  • 4/28/2017

                    D.C. Circuit grants 60-day abeyance; orders EPA to provide 30 day status updates. Abeyance granted through approximately June 27.

                  more
                  Notes/Info/Chamber/Statements

                  Global Energy Institute statement on proposed repeal of Clean Power Plan (10/10/17)

                  Energy Institute information on Clean Power Plan and EPA carbon regulations.

                  Litigation details at U.S. Chamber Litigation Center.

                  Case: West Virginia v. EPA, No. 15-1363 (D.C. Cir.)

                  Topic
                  Air Regulations
                  Issue/Reg
                  MATS "Supplemental Findings"
                  Order/Action
                  • 4/25/2016

                    EPA issues Supplemental Finding responding to court remand of original MATS regulation.

                  Most Recent Action
                  Litigation
                  • 1/19/2018

                    EPA submits its status report stating that it continues to review the final rule to determine whether the rule should be “maintained, modified or otherwise reconsidered.”

                  • 10/24/2017

                    EPA submits its status report stating that it continues to review the Supplemental Finding to determine whether the rule should be “maintained, modified or otherwise reconsidered.”

                  • 7/26/2017

                    EPA submits its status report stating that EPA is continuing to review its finding to determine whether the rule should be “maintained, modified or otherwise reconsidered.”

                  • 4/27/2017

                    D.C. Circuit order in response to DOJ/EPA request postpones May 18 oral arguments; grants 90-day abeyance.

                  • 4/25/2017

                    Industry files petition for review of final agency action regarding findings for coal- and oil-fired energy generating units. 

                  more
                  Notes/Info/Chamber/Statements

                  Case: Murray Energy v. EPA, No. 16-1127 (D.C. Cir.)

                  Topic
                  Air Regulations
                  Issue/Reg
                  Methane ICR (Existing Sources)
                  Order/Action
                  • 3/2/2017

                    EPA withdraws 2016 information collection request (ICR) pertaining to methane emissions from existing oil and gas operations.

                  Most Recent Action
                  Litigation
                    Notes/Info/Chamber/Statements

                    Letter from governors and attorneys general to EPA requesting withdrawal of ICR.

                    Topic
                    Air Regulations
                    Issue/Reg
                    Methane NSPS
                    Order/Action
                    • 3/12/2018

                      EPA finalizes proposal to stay deadlines pertaining to stay certain requirements associated with 2016 methane NSPS rule.

                    • 11/8/2017

                      EPA issues notice seeking comment on numerous aspects of its June 2017 proposal to stay certain requirements of the 2016 rule.

                      (Agency fact sheet)

                    • 6/16/2017

                      EPA issues order proposing to stay for two years the implementation of 2016 new source performance standards pertaining to methane in oil and gas production during review and reconsideration of the rule. 

                    • 6/5/2017

                      EPA issues a 90-day stay of agency rules limiting methane leaks at drilling sites.

                    more
                    Most Recent Action
                    Litigation
                    • 8/10/2017

                      Industry and State petitioners’ request for a rehearing en banc denied.

                    • 7/31/2017

                      D.C. Circuit en banc panel vacates EPA’s 90-day pause of methane rule implementation for new oil and gas sources, putting the rule back into effect.

                    • 7/13/2017

                      D.C. Circuit grants EPA request to delay enforcement of methane NSPS regulation for 14 days while the agency considers whether to appeal the ruling. (EPA had requested 45 day enforcement delay).

                    • 7/3/2017

                      D.C. Circuit invalidates EPA two-year administrative stay of 2016 methane NSPS regulation; orders immediate enforcement of rule.

                    • 6/5/2017

                      Environmental petitioners file for review of EPA’s final action staying its own standards of performance for the oil and gas sector.

                    more
                    Notes/Info/Chamber/Statements

                    Case: Clean Air Council v. EPA, No. 17-1145 (D.C. Cir.)

                    Topic
                    Air Regulations
                    Issue/Reg
                    Ozone NAAQS
                    Order/Action
                    • 3/9/2018

                      EPA issues threshold implementation guidance setting attainment timelines for 2015 ozone rule.

                      (Agency fact sheet)

                    • 1/5/2018

                      EPA announces its intention to complete attainment designations for the 2015 ozone standard by 4/30/18.

                    • 11/16/2017

                      EPA issues attainment designations for 2,646 counties under the 2015 ozone standard; indicates remaining designations (15% of U.S. counties) will be issued at a later date.

                      (News Summary)

                    • 8/2/2017

                      EPA withdraws prior decision to extending attainment designation deadlines.

                    • 6/7/2017

                      EPA postpones 2015 ozone standard attainment designations for one year, citing insufficient information to make compliance decision.

                    more
                    Most Recent Action
                    Litigation
                    • 3/12/2018

                      Court enters order granting NGO plaintiffs’ and state plaintiffs’ motions for summary judgment, confirming that the Administrator violated a nondiscretionary duty under the Clean Air Act to promulgate NAAQS for Ozone by Oct 1, 2017 (No. 17-6900).

                    • 2/16/2018

                      D.C. Cir. issues an opinion ruling that 1) EPA failed to adopt adequate anti-backsliding measures when it revoked the 1997 NAAQS, 2) EPA violated the CAA by allowing so-called “orphan nonattainment areas” to evade anti-backsliding requirements, 3) the rule’s invitation of “redesignation substitute requests” evaded the statutory requirements for redesignations, and 4) EPA failed to provide a statutory justification for allowing states to choose their own baseline year for measuring pollution reductions (No. 15-1115).

                       

                    • 1/31/2018

                      State of California files its reply in support of motion for summary judgment.

                       

                    • 1/26/2018

                      Environmental groups file their reply in support of motion for summary judgment.

                    • 1/19/2018

                      EPA files its opposition  to environmental group plaintiffs’ motion for summary judgment.

                       

                    • 1/8/2018

                      EPA submits status report,  stating it is continuing to review the Rule in Murray Energy.

                    • 10/10/2017

                      EPA submits status report stating it is continuing to review the Rule.

                    • 8/1/2017

                      Coalition of 15 states sues EPA to block postponement of ozone standard implementation. 

                    • 7/10/2017

                      In its 90-day status report, EPA states it is continuing to review Rule. EPA will submit its next status report within 90 days.

                    • 4/11/2017

                      D.C. Circuit grants indefinite abeyance of 2015 ozone standard lawsuit, delaying previously scheduled oral argument and ordering EPA to provide updates at 90 day intervals.

                    • 10/26/2015

                      Industry petitioners file for review of agency’s proposed Ozone NAAQS rule.

                    more
                    Notes/Info/Chamber/Statements
                    Topic
                    Air Regulations
                    Issue/Reg
                    Power Plant CO2 New Source Performance Standards (NSPS)
                    Order/Action
                    • 3/28/2017

                      Section 4 of Executive Order 13783 directs review and reconsideration of NSPS for new power plants (CCS mandate for new coal plants).

                    Most Recent Action
                    Litigation
                    • 1/25/2018

                      EPA files status report stating the agency is continuing its review of the rule.

                    • 10/27/2017

                      EPA files status report stating the agency is continuing its review of the rule.

                    • 10/27/2017

                      In update to court, EPA states that it is continuing its review of the rule.

                    • 8/10/2017

                      Court orders cases remain held in abeyance; Respondent to file status reports at 90-day intervals starting Oct. 27.

                    • 7/31/2017

                      In update to court, EPA states that it continues to review the rule.

                    • 6/29/2017

                      In update to court EPA states that it continues to review the rule.

                    • 4/28/2017

                      DC Circuit grants 60-day abeyance of lawsuit against NSPS regulation while EPA reviews the rule; orders EPA to provide 30 day status updates. Case has been briefed but oral argument not set.

                    • 10/23/2015

                      State petitioner files for review of agency final rule on Greenhouse Gas emissions.

                    more
                    Notes/Info/Chamber/Statements

                    Litigation details at U.S. Chamber Litigation Center

                    Case: North Dakota v. EPA, No. 15-1381, (D.C. Cir.)

                    Topic
                    Air Regulations
                    Issue/Reg
                    Regional Haze
                    Order/Action
                    • 9/29/2017

                      EPA finalizes withdrawal of regional haze FIP for Texas.

                    Most Recent Action
                    Litigation
                    • 8/31/2017

                      U.S. District Court for D.C. rejects EPA request to delay deadline for development of Texas’ regional haze plan in response to 2012 consent decree.

                    Notes/Info/Chamber/Statements
                    Topic
                    Air Regulations
                    Issue/Reg
                    Regional Haze
                    Order/Action
                      Most Recent Action
                      Litigation
                      • 3/12/2018

                        In status report to 10th Circuit, EPA says it plans to develop a new regional haze plan for Utah after completing new air quality modeling simulations later this spring. 

                      • 9/11/2017

                        10th Circuit grants request from PacifiCorp and State of Utah to stay litigation on EPA’s 2016 regional haze federal implementation plan (FIP) while EPA reconsiders the rule.

                      Notes/Info/Chamber/Statements
                      Topic
                      Air Regulations
                      Issue/Reg
                      Regional Haze
                      Order/Action
                      • 2/12/2018

                        EPA announces final withdrawal of federal implementation plan, and approval of revised regional haze state implementation plan for Arkansas.

                      • 9/11/2017

                        EPA announces withdrawal of NOX portion of Arkansas regional haze FIP and approval of revised state implementation plan.

                      • 7/13/2017

                        EPA extends compliance deadline for September 2016 Arkansas Regional Haze Federal Implementation Plan (FIP) from April 2018 to January 2020.

                      more
                      Most Recent Action
                      Litigation
                      • 2/1/2018

                        Entergy files its reply in support of its motion to stay.

                      • 1/25/2018

                        Environmental groups file their response to Entergy’s motion to stay.

                      • 1/22/2018

                        EPA files its response to Entergy’s motion to stay.

                      • 1/11/2018

                        Entergy files motion to stay EPA’s final rule.

                      • 1/11/2018

                        Environmental groups file their amended response to State of Arkansas’s stay motion.

                      • 1/10/2018

                        EPA files its response to State of Arkansas’s motion for stay of final rule.

                      • 1/4/2018

                        Court grants EPA’s motion to hold petitions in abeyance for 90 days against opposition by Entergy and Environmental Groups.

                      • 1/2/2018

                        Environmental groups file their response to Entergy’s opposition.

                      • 12/29/2017

                        EPA files reply in support of motion to hold litigation in abeyance.

                      • 12/26/2017

                        Environmental groups file their opposition to State of Arkansas’s stay motion.

                         

                      • 11/1/2017

                        8th Circuit grants additional abeyance of case through 12/15/17.

                      • 7/31/2017

                        8th Circuit grants 2-month abeyance of case on Arkansas Regional Haze FIP in response to Arkansas/EPA request. Abeyance granted through 9/26/17. 

                      • 11/23/2016

                        Private petitioner files for review of Agency final rule regarding Regional Haze.

                      more
                      Notes/Info/Chamber/Statements

                      Multi-association letter to EPA on proposed Arkansas Regional Haze FIP.

                      Case: AK Affordable Energy Coalition v. EPA, No. 16-4270 (8th Cir.)

                      More info on U.S. Chamber regional haze litigation activity

                      Topic
                      Air Regulations
                      Issue/Reg
                      Social Cost of Carbon
                      Order/Action
                      • 3/28/2017

                        Section 5 of Executive Order 13783 disbands the Interagency Working Group on the Social Cost of Carbon and rescinds use of its guidance and support documents.

                      Most Recent Action
                      Litigation
                        Notes/Info/Chamber/Statements
                        Topic
                        Air Regulations
                        Issue/Reg
                        Startup, Shutdown, Malfunction (SSM)
                        Order/Action
                          Most Recent Action
                          Litigation
                          • 1/19/2018

                            EPA files its third 90-day status report.

                          • 10/23/2017

                            EPA files its second 90-day status report.

                          • 7/24/2017

                            EPA files first abeyance reporting indicating that it continues to review the SSM rule.

                          • 4/24/2017

                            D.C. Circuit grants DOJ/EPA request to delay scheduled oral arguments in case challenging 2015 EPA rule on SSM requirements while EPA reconsiders the rule. The Court’s order places the SSM legal challenge in abeyance for 90 days, and requires EPA to submit a 90 day status report.

                          • 6/12/2015

                            Environmental and industry groups file for review of Agency final rule regarding State Implementation Plans’ SSM policies. 

                          more
                          Notes/Info/Chamber/Statements

                          Case: Envtl. Comm. FL Elec. Power Coordinating Grp. v. EPA, No. 15-1239 (D.C. Cir.)

                          Topic
                          Air Regulations
                          Issue/Reg
                          Venting and Flaring
                          Order/Action
                          • 2/22/2018

                            BLM publishes proposed revisions to the Methane and Waste Prevention Rule

                            (Agency press release)

                            (Comment docket)

                          • 2/12/2018

                            BLM announces proposal to revise Methane Waste Prevention Rule.

                            (Agency press release)

                             

                          • 12/8/2017

                            BLM finalizes proposal to delay implementation of venting and flaring rule until January 2019.

                          • 10/5/2017

                            BLM formally proposes to temporarily suspend implementation of 2016 venting and flaring rule until January 2019. 

                          • 6/15/2017

                            BLM announces it will suspend implementation of certain provisions of November 2016 Methane Waste Prevention Rule (aka Venting and Flaring) that have yet to go into effect.

                          • 3/28/2017

                            Section 7 of Executive Order 13783 directs review and reconsideration of Department of Interior methane regulations for oil and gas production on federal lands (aka venting and flaring).

                          more
                          Most Recent Action
                          Litigation
                          • 3/15/2018

                            9th Cir. enters order granting Appellants’ voluntary motion to dismiss.

                          • 3/14/2018

                            Appellants file voluntary motion to dismiss appeal.

                          • 12/8/2017

                            Case docketed before the Court of Appeals for the 9th Circuit.

                          • 12/4/2017

                            BLM files Notice of Appeal to the Ninth Cir.

                          • 10/4/2017

                            U.S. District Court for Northern California invalidates Department of Interior’s administrative stay of BLM methane waste prevention rule.

                          • 7/5/2017

                            State petitioners file suit against the Bureau of Land Management for postponing the compliance date of the Waste Prevention, Production Subject to Royalties and Resource Conservation rule.

                          more
                          Notes/Info/Chamber/Statements

                          Chamber key vote letter supporting congressional repeal of venting and flaring rule (5/9/17).

                          Coalition letter supporting congressional repeal of venting and flaring rule (2/2/17).

                          Case: California v. BLM, no. 17-cv-03804-EDL (N.D. Ca.)

                          Case: California v. BLM, no. 17-17456 (9th Cir.).

                          Topic
                          Electricity
                          Issue/Reg
                          Grid Management
                          Order/Action
                          • 1/8/2018

                            FERC rejects DOE grid resiliency proposal and initiates new proceeding to study the issue further. FERC

                            (Agency release)

                          • 10/10/2017

                            Department of Energy proposes Grid Resiliency Pricing Rule under Federal Power Act calling on FERC to order changes to pricing of resiliency and reliability attributes.

                          • 10/4/2017

                            FERC releases scoping questions for comment period on DOE Grid Reliability and Resiliency Pricing proposal.

                          more
                          Most Recent Action
                          Litigation
                            Notes/Info/Chamber/Statements
                            Topic
                            Endangered Species Act
                            Issue/Reg
                            Sage Grouse
                            Order/Action
                            • 1/3/2018

                              BLM issues Sage Grouse Scoping Report.

                            • 12/27/2017

                              BLM instruction memorandum 2018-26 details guidance for implementing oil and gas leasing and development objectives as part of the greater sage-grouse resource management plan revisions.

                            • 8/7/2017

                              Sage Grouse Review Team delivers report to Secretary Zinke in response to Secretarial Order 3353.

                            • 6/7/2017

                              Secretary Zinke signs Secretarial Order 3353 establishing a Sage Grouse Review Team to study federal and state sage grouse protection plans and related economic implications.

                            • 10/11/2017

                              BLM announces plans to review land use provisions in the federal sage grouse conservation plan, and opens public comment period on scoping the review. In separate notice, BLM withdraws proposal relating to restrictions on 10 million acres of National Forest system lands in Sagebrush Focal Areas (SFAs).

                              (News Summary)

                            more
                            Most Recent Action
                            Litigation
                              Notes/Info/Chamber/Statements
                              Topic
                              Energy Financial / Royalties
                              Issue/Reg
                              Extractive Industries Payment Disclosure
                              Order/Action
                              • 2/14/2017

                                Public Law 115-4 using Congressional Review Act authority to repeal Securities and Exchange Commission regulations mandating public disclosure of reports of energy company finances and operations. 

                              Most Recent Action
                              Litigation
                                Topic
                                Energy Financial / Royalties
                                Issue/Reg
                                Multilateral Development Banks (MDBs)
                                Order/Action
                                • 7/17/2017

                                  Department of Treasury modifies Obama Administration guidance prohibiting U.S. support for financing construction of coal plants internationally through MDBs, committing to “help countries access and use fossil fuels more cleanly and efficiently.”

                                Most Recent Action
                                Litigation
                                  Notes/Info/Chamber/Statements
                                  Topic
                                  Energy Financial / Royalties
                                  Issue/Reg
                                  Office of Natural Resources Revenue (ONRR) Royalty Valuation Rule
                                  Order/Action
                                  • 8/7/2017

                                    Interior’s Office of Natural Resources Revenue finalizes repeal of 2017 Valuation Rule.

                                     

                                    (Comment docket)

                                  • 4/4/2017

                                    Department of Interior’s ONRR formally proposes to repeal 2017 Valuation Rule pertaining to oil, gas, and coal royalties.

                                  • 2/22/2017

                                    Department of Interior’s ONRR announces stay of 2017 Valuation Rule pertaining to oil, gas, and coal royalties.

                                    (News Summary)

                                  more
                                  Most Recent Action
                                  Litigation
                                  • 10/25/2017

                                    Court denies Plaintiffs’ motion to relate the two rule delay challenges.

                                  • 10/23/2017

                                    Defendants file opposition to Plaintiffs’ motion.

                                  • 10/18/2017

                                    Plaintiffs file move to relate the challenge to the Delayed Royalty Rule to Plaintiffs’ challenge to the delay of the Department’s Coal Valuation Reform rule.

                                  • 8/30/2017

                                    U.S. District Court for Northern California invalidates ONRR stay of Royalty Rule.

                                  • 2/22/2017

                                    State petitioners file for injunctive relief to stop the Department of Interior implementation of the Royalty Rule. 

                                  more
                                  Notes/Info/Chamber/Statements

                                  U.S. Chamber letter to House Natural Resources Committee supporting revisions to ONRR Valuation Rule (item VIII).

                                  Case: Becerra v. Dep’t of Interior, No. 17-cv-02376-EDL (N.D. Cal.)

                                  Topic
                                  Energy Infrastructure
                                  Issue/Reg
                                  Energy Infrastructure
                                  Order/Action
                                  • 7/19/2017

                                    Executive Order 13805 establishes Infrastructure Advisory Council within Department of Commerce to report on “funding, support, and delivery of infrastructure projects in several sectors including renewable energy, electricity transmission, and pipelines.”

                                  Most Recent Action
                                  Litigation
                                    Notes/Info/Chamber/Statements
                                    Topic
                                    General / Energy Development
                                    Issue/Reg
                                    Energy Independence
                                    Order/Action
                                    Most Recent Action
                                    Litigation
                                      Notes/Info/Chamber/Statements

                                      Draft final agency recommendations due to OMB in 120 days (July 26th, 2017).

                                      Final report due in 180 days (September 24th, 201)

                                      Topic
                                      General / Energy Development
                                      Issue/Reg
                                      Energy Independence
                                      Order/Action
                                      • 3/29/2017

                                        Secretary Zinke signs Secretarial Order 3349, directing Department of Interior reviews of numerous regulations and policies impacting energy development.

                                      Most Recent Action
                                      Litigation
                                        Notes/Info/Chamber/Statements
                                        X